What reduces emissions more?One could also upgrade from the SUV to the Prius, of course, or walk or ride your bike.
A. Someone swapping their old SUV (which gets 12 miles per gallon) for a hybrid version (18 mpg)
B. someone upgrading their 25 mpg compact to a new 46 mpg Prius?
(ignore for a minute manufacturing issues or driving habits and assume the miles driven are the same).
The surprising answer (for those who don't work it out) is A. It's easy enough to see why this is the case. If the driving distance is 100 miles, then for case A the saving in fuel used (and hence emissions) is 100/12-100/18 = 2.8 gallons, while for B, you have 100/25-100/46 = 1.8 gallons. The confusion arises because people like to think linearly about numbers, not inversely, and so tend to assume that a similar change in mpg has a similar impact on fuel usage. This is not however the case - improvements in efficiency at the low end of the scale are much more useful at reducing emissions. This is actually a very general point - when trying to raise efficiency it is always
sensible to start with the least efficient processes.
Monday, November 10, 2008
Reducing your transportation emissions
From the Real Climate blog: